View Issue Details

IDProjectCategoryView StatusLast Update
0001961SpeedFanFan controlpublic2012-03-22 01:01
ReporterhellomelonAssigned Toalfredo 
PriorityhighSeveritymajorReproducibilityalways
Status assignedResolutionopen 
PlatformWindowsOSWindows 7 SP1OS Version64bit
Product Version4.45 
Target VersionFixed in Version 
Summary0001961: ATK0110 no Fan Control
DescriptionI can see all temps (CPU, Aux, System,GPU , MB, NB, HDD). But only the Fans Controlled by the Winbond W83667HG SuperIO Chip are adjustable in speed( and are shown as Speed0,Speed1,Speed2,Speed3). The ATK0110 Controlled Fans(like CHA_1-3 Fans, the 2nd CPU Fan) are not adjustable in Speed and there isnt even a Speed Marker for them. Furthermore the ATK0110 Fans are Shown with Adress $0 in Settings.
Things I've tried:
-Enable/Disable Q-Fan in Bios -> don't work
-Download a Configuration File -> there is no
-Download newest beta -> problem persists
-Install the ATK0110 Driver -> problem persists

I've included the debug.nfo as well as 3 Screenshots of the Settings and the main Window.
Steps To ReproduceJust open it.
Additional InformationScreenshots:

http://imageshack.us/g/607/screenshot3ko.png/
TagsNo tags attached.
Motherboard ModelAsus Rampage II Extreme
Video Card ModelSapphire Radeon HD 4890 Vapor-X 2GB

Activities

hellomelon

2012-03-21 20:50

reporter  

debug.nfo (100,904 bytes)

_lunchbox_

2012-03-21 21:17

reporter   ~0006896

Why would you want to control via ATK and not WinBond? I don't see what the benefit might be.

I get the feeling that the ATK stuff is always read only anyway...

hellomelon

2012-03-21 22:07

reporter   ~0006897

UPDATE:
my mainboard has 7 3 Pin Fan connectors:
3x Chassis(CHA_FAN1 - 3)
3x Optional Fan(OPT_FAN1-3)
1x CPU_FAN
1x PWR_FAN

and i only have 4 speeds. 1 Speed for all 3 CHA_Fans and 2 Speeds refer to fan that aren't connected and the 4th is for my Graphics. Strange thing about that is that the 2nd Speed is assigned to the CPU Fan and it actually the speed of 3! Fans at once. Furthermore i'm not able to control both cpu fans which are connected to the CPU_Fan Connecter and the PWR_fan Connecter.

_lunchbox_

2012-03-21 22:12

reporter   ~0006898

Most ASUS boards have chassis fan and option fans WIRED together, so there is no way to control them independently. It's a limitation of how ASUS wired the boards. That's why you only have 4 speeds. One of them is probably unused.

PWR_FAN is not controllable. Again, it's how ASUS implemented it.

CPU_FAN can be controlled. I couldn't control it on my board until I changed the PWM Mode of all PWMs to Manual. Check the WinBond settings under CONFIGURE->ADVANCED->Winbond chip.

My guess is that one of your speeds is unused by ASUS. The other three control the CPU, all Chassis fans and all option fans. Try changing the speeds and see which fans respond, then label them appropriately.

hellomelon

2012-03-21 22:31

reporter   ~0006899

you are my hero :) thats what i've missed. if i change the pwn mode 1 to Manual then i'm able to control the Chassis Fan peferct via the Speed01 Toggle, the Speed04 toggle(my graphic card) also works like a charm. but i can't get my cpu fan controlable. under Settings-> The Sensor CPU is assigned to Speed02 but i've tried every combination under PWM Mode 2 and the Fan connected to the CPU_Fan Connecter(which is as i've found out a 4 pin connector) won't respond, furthermore the speed is shown as zero. any idea?

_lunchbox_

2012-03-21 22:33

reporter   ~0006900

Yea.

I believe the CPU fan must be a 4 pin fan for it to be controllable via the 4 pin header. a 3pin fan won't be controllable :(

hellomelon

2012-03-21 22:37

reporter   ~0006901

-.- that's really ridicolous -.- maybe it would work if i connect the 2 cpu fans to the OPT_Fan connectors? ah wait i'll try it.

_lunchbox_

2012-03-21 22:45

reporter   ~0006902

That should work via one of the speeds, I think.

hellomelon

2012-03-21 22:54

reporter   ~0006903

ok now they are recognized as OPT_FAN1 and OPT_FAN3 but still no control via Speed02 or Speed03, PWM MODE is all on Manual, should i try to change it? or is this maybe because the CPU Fans are Noctua ones and the Chassis fans are Revoltec ones?

_lunchbox_

2012-03-22 01:01

reporter   ~0006904

Hmm, are you sure the PWM's are still set to manual? If you don't check the 'remember it' check box it will get set back.

Do you know if Qfan will control the opt fans? If it can, speedfan can probably control them.

I don't think fan brand should matter too much.

Issue History

Date Modified Username Field Change
2012-03-21 20:50 hellomelon New Issue
2012-03-21 20:50 hellomelon Status new => assigned
2012-03-21 20:50 hellomelon Assigned To => alfredo
2012-03-21 20:50 hellomelon File Added: debug.nfo
2012-03-21 21:17 _lunchbox_ Note Added: 0006896
2012-03-21 22:07 hellomelon Note Added: 0006897
2012-03-21 22:12 _lunchbox_ Note Added: 0006898
2012-03-21 22:31 hellomelon Note Added: 0006899
2012-03-21 22:33 _lunchbox_ Note Added: 0006900
2012-03-21 22:37 hellomelon Note Added: 0006901
2012-03-21 22:45 _lunchbox_ Note Added: 0006902
2012-03-21 22:54 hellomelon Note Added: 0006903
2012-03-22 01:01 _lunchbox_ Note Added: 0006904